Professional Soldiers

Professional Soldiers (http://www.professionalsoldiers.com/forums/index.php)
-   Special Forces Assessment & Selection (http://www.professionalsoldiers.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=26)
-   -   1LT NTR / Need Advice (http://www.professionalsoldiers.com/forums/showthread.php?t=55079)

PretzelFactory 09-15-2020 10:28

1LT NTR / Need Advice
 
I am a 1LT, National Guard, 20th GRP candidate. Recently I received an NTR at SFAS. (2nd attempt)

First attempt, I went in Oct, passed gate week no problem, but was dropped for psych. 2014 I got a DUI (before military / commissioning). This is the part on the psych where you note any past criminal experiences. I also did not think I needed a waiver.

Second attempt: BLUF: Failed to meet 12mile ruck time. I decided to go during the Aug class, and I totally should have listened to my SFRE cadre that heat can really effect you during this class. I never felt so sluggish / total disconnect with my body and simply could not get myself to shuffle or move at a moving speed.

------------------------

Moving forward: The NG Liaison informed me that individuals have dropped their commission and went back as enlisted (E-5) for another shot. Has anyone on this forum dropped their commission and went in as E-5?

The NG Liaison mentioned that if I were to come back as an E-5, I should definitely bring a waiver to have the psych portion cleaned up. However what worries me, even if I brought a waiver, there is a possibility you could still be dropped...

-----------------------

Additional thoughts: I whole hardheartedly want to be part of GRP, and if it takes to drop my commission to go back, I want this to happen. I just want to hear some view points from members on this forum. Another note, I do have a full time job out of the National Guard.

Thanks

Basenshukai 09-15-2020 10:39

Quote:

Originally Posted by PretzelFactory (Post 662411)
I am a 1LT, National Guard, 20th GRP candidate. Recently I received an NTR at SFAS. (2nd attempt)

First attempt, I went in Oct, passed gate week no problem, but was dropped for psych. 2014 I got a DUI (before military / commissioning). This is the part on the psych where you note any past criminal experiences. I also did not think I needed a waiver.

Second attempt: BLUF: Failed to meet 12mile ruck time. I decided to go during the Aug class, and I totally should have listened to my SFRE cadre that heat can really effect you during this class. I never felt so sluggish / total disconnect with my body and simply could not get myself to shuffle or move at a moving speed.

------------------------

Moving forward: The NG Liaison informed me that individuals have dropped their commission and went back as enlisted (E-5) for another shot. Has anyone on this forum dropped their commission and went in as E-5?

The NG Liaison mentioned that if I were to come back as an E-5, I should definitely bring a waiver to have the psych portion cleaned up. However what worries me, even if I brought a waiver, there is a possibility you could still be dropped...

-----------------------

Additional thoughts: I whole hardheartedly want to be part of GRP, and if it takes to drop my commission to go back, I want this to happen. I just want to hear some view points from members on this forum. Another note, I do have a full time job out of the National Guard.

Thanks

I don't have a lot to add from an advise perspective. But, realize that giving someone an NTR in SFAS is not done lightly. I was an instructor there for a short stint and I can tell you that they put a lot of thought into whom and why they NTR a candidate, and it is not usually just one thing. For example, during my SFAS class we had a candidate who failed to come in within standard during the last long ruckmarch. But, it was discovered that he was pulling off the march on a broken foot. He got selected. The cadre uses the whole man concept in SFAS. If you were a no-go twice, you might want to consider that this may not be the career choice for you.

CSB 09-15-2020 11:52

You have attempted twice. More than many who did not try at all. As noted, this should have struck you that this particular branch of a very large Army is not to be your branch. If you are in some sense asking if a third try as an enlisted member is an option, I will tell you that it is not in your best interest nor the best interest of the Army. Be the best officer you can be within the branch you hold now.
Where can you contribute more to our nation? As an officer, or as an NCO with MAYBE chance of Special Forces, while denying our country a man who sounds like a solid 1LT with prospects of Captain if not much higher. It’s not about you, it’s about the bigger picture.

ic2d 10-08-2020 16:13

Quote:

Originally Posted by PretzelFactory (Post 662411)
Has anyone on this forum dropped their commission and went in as E-5?

I did. Too much TIG to go to SFAS as an O, so I tried the next best thing.

I have no idea if enlisting would help overturn your NTR, but generally speaking I have to agree with CSB's comments. Your prior training and experience have taught you to be an officer, not an NCO.

That's not to say you can't adapt and become a stellar NCO, but the mindset shift has been more challenging for me than I expected. Then again, I also came from the Air Force...and active duty. So, not exactly apples to apples.

Let me know if you have specific questions.

(For what it's worth, we might have gone to SFAS together. Were you in the class starting at the beginning of Oct, or the class starting near the end of the month? I was in the latter.)

Astronomy 10-08-2020 18:14

Echoing the other posters: Two times at bat is enough... and a clue.

Stick with commissioned life and excel at that. 20 some years down the road, you'll be thankful you did. That horizon is difficult to visualize right now, but it's real. Rewarding professionally, educationally, and financially... in ways you can't yet appreciate.

Do Not Give Up Your Commission to become an NCO.

Be the finest Officer possible... and forge another path to satisfy your personal goals.

PRB 10-09-2020 10:52

We appreciate your try...sincerely.

An NTR is not based upon one or two failed events but an overall assessment that takes into consideration other factors.
It is not given by one individual but a selected board.

The chances of returning as an enlisted probably do not exist and you would be making a serious change in your military career.

I was the CSM of the Battalion that SFAS fell under and then the Training Group CSM.

Box 10-09-2020 11:04

Quote:

Originally Posted by ic2d (Post 662985)
I did. Too much TIG to go to SFAS as an O, so I tried the next best thing.

So, what was the result?

ic2d 10-13-2020 20:03

Quote:

Originally Posted by Box (Post 662993)
So, what was the result?

I got a shot at SFAS.

I was not selected.

In my case (high TIG with an MOS that did not transfer to the Army), the officer reinstatement rules were, and still are, rather unfavorable. Thus, my decision to enlist wasn't only about SFAS.

While I don't necessarily regret the decision, I have personally experienced many of the considerations pointed out by other posters in this thread. They're not insignificant.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:58.


Copyright 2004-2020 by Professional Soldiers